High: All staff we met was very polite with one exception..The newness is pretty cool. The view is almost 180 degrees and quite beautiful. We had the windmill/sewage treatment plant view. Feather pillows are standard. Low: There is no organization at check-in, just some guests milling about waiting to be next. The rooms are tiny. maybe slightly larger than the... more

I was disappointed with the room I had at the Water Club. There was only one chair (desk chair) so there wasn't a comfortable place to sit. I didn't like the mini bar and would have preferred to have a refrigerator I could use. Also, you had to be careful not to move the items on the tray (water, wine,... more

The Water Club is the perfect hotel, it is stunning. The lobby is very elegant, the rooms are even nicer. Though not worth the 1,100 maximum daily rate they are the best in the area. If your coming to Atlantic City for the hotel experience, stay at The Water Club. The Borgata (which is connected to The Water Club) has... more

I accidentally left an eyeglass case that had my ipod in it after checking out. I brought it to the attention of Lost and Found, and only the case was turned in, not the ipod. I've stayed in lesser hotels that sent back gold chains. This violation of trust is unacceptable in a hotel of this class. I brought it... more

We had a comp room at the Borgota but they told my wife we could stay at the Water club if we wanted so we moved on over. The room is layed out pretty nice and we had a nice view of the windmill generation plant but there were a few negative issues. My wife really likes her coffee first... more

From the time you enter The Water Club, you are definitely experiencing luxury. The staff is very helpful and friendly. The lobby and surrounding areas are magnificent. The rooms are extremely nice with all the highest quality amenities. We have stayed at the Water Club on 2 different occasions; the view from both rooms was awesome. The beds are so... more

Let me preface my review by disclosing that I am always comped at the Borgata for my stays. So my review for my first visit to the Water Club might definitely be different if I was paying $449 per night. Never-the-less this may be insightful to those not sure which hotel to stay at (original Borgata hotel or the new... more

My son and I gamble at the Borgata about twice a month. We usually stay at the Borgata. The Borgata was full so we got comped at the Water Club instead. As a previous poster states, "the Water Club has too many rules". Most of these rules are designed to gouge you for more money. For example, the first time... more

This is a gorgeous hotel and please keep that in mind when reading this (and other) reviews. They have a huge opportunity to make this one of the best stays on the entire east coast if they change some things and play their cards right. The first change needs to be their overall attitude towards their guests. We did have... more